top of page

The Oligarch, the Journalists and the Courtroom: A Test of Press Freedom in Wartime Ukraine

42 minutes ago
12 min read

By Matthew Parish


Monday 16 November 2026


On 17 November 2026, a Kyiv court is scheduled to begin preliminary proceedings in a dispute arising from investigative reporting about Russian oligarch Oleg Boyko. Behind an apparently conventional defamation claim lies a much larger question: how should a democratic country at war protect the freedom of journalists to scrutinise powerful commercial interests, particularly when those interests extend across the frontiers separating Russia, Ukraine and the European Union?


There is something distinctly paradoxical about the spectacle of a Russian oligarch resorting to the courts of Ukraine to challenge journalism concerning his commercial interests. Ukraine is fighting an existential war against Russian imperialism, its citizens are dying defending the country's independence and its institutions are struggling to preserve the principles of democratic government under the most difficult imaginable circumstances. Yet one of those very principles is that the courts remain open to anyone with a legitimate legal grievance, however unpopular that person may be.


On 17 November 2026, the Shevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv is scheduled to hold a preparatory hearing in civil case number 761/30980/26, concerning the protection of honour, dignity and business reputation. The defendant is the non-governmental organisation Euromaidan Press, publisher of one of Ukraine's prominent English-language news outlets. The proceedings arise against the background of legal demands made on behalf of Oleg Boyko following two investigative articles published in June 2026. The court's publicly available order anonymises the claimant, so Boyko's identification with the proceedings rests on information supplied about the case and the publicly documented correspondence from his lawyers.


The hearing is scheduled for 1.30 pm before Judge Yu. N. Savchuk, at 31-A Dehtiarivska Street in Kyiv. The court's order of 3 August 2026 opened ordinary civil proceedings and established the timetable for the parties' written submissions. It did not determine whether anything published by Euromaidan Press was false, defamatory or unlawful, nor did it make findings about Boyko's business activities. Those are matters that remain to be examined.


This distinction is fundamental. An allegation is not a judicial finding, a sanctions designation is not a criminal conviction and the right to bring proceedings is not itself evidence that the proceedings are abusive. Equally, the existence of litigation must not become a means of discouraging journalists from investigating matters of legitimate public concern. The difficult task is to preserve all these principles simultaneously, even when the underlying dispute concerns some of the most politically sensitive questions in contemporary Europe.


The origins of the dispute lie in two articles published by Euromaidan Press on 1 and 2 June 2026, both written by Peeter Helme. The first, entitled A Putin-list oligarch runs Poland’s vape market. The EU won’t sanction him, explored the international business connections of Boyko, the Russian financier associated with the Finstar Financial Group and the consumer lending industry. It examined allegations concerning his connections with Poland's electronic cigarette industry, particularly the Evapify business network, and the apparent inconsistencies in the sanctions imposed upon him by different Western governments.


Boyko's position is unusual. He appeared on the American Treasury Department's so-called Putin List of 2018, although inclusion in that document did not itself constitute the imposition of American sanctions. He has been subjected to sanctions by Ukraine, Australia and Poland, while the European Union has not included him on its own sanctions list. Canada previously imposed sanctions upon him but subsequently removed him from its list. These distinctions matter because sanctions are instruments of government policy rather than criminal convictions, and because the absence of sanctions in one jurisdiction does not invalidate their imposition in another.


The Polish position is especially interesting. On 12 December 2024, Poland's Ministry of the Interior and Administration adopted a formal decision imposing restrictions upon Boyko following an application from the Polish Internal Security Agency. The agency alleged that he maintained connections with Russian intelligence services and organised criminal structures. These were allegations recorded in an official administrative decision, not findings of criminal guilt, but their incorporation into a government sanctions decision makes them matters of obvious public interest. The decision also examined historical financial and ownership connections involving the 4Finance lending group.


The second Euromaidan Press article, published on 2 June under the title Ukraine’s vape market is 93% illegal. The trail leads to a sanctioned Russian oligarch, explored another dimension of this international commercial story. Its subject was the enormous illicit market in electronic cigarettes in Ukraine, including the financial losses that the Ukrainian government allegedly incurs through the smuggling and untaxed distribution of these products.


The article cited research by Kantar Ukraine suggesting that more than 93 per cent of the Ukrainian electronic cigarette market was operating illegally, together with estimates from the Growford Institute that unpaid excise duty and value-added tax from this market exceeded 7.6 billion hryvnias in 2025. The Kantar research had been commissioned by major tobacco manufacturers, a commercial interest that readers should know about when assessing the figures. Nevertheless, the scale of the reported fiscal losses is remarkable. Ukraine is a country desperately seeking additional resources for its armed forces, and the possibility that billions of hryvnias are disappearing into illicit commercial networks deserves the closest scrutiny.


The investigation drew connections between individuals involved in the Evapify businesses and those previously associated with Boyko's financial operations. Among them were executives whose careers had passed through the 4Finance group before their involvement with electronic cigarettes. Euromaidan Press presented this network of relationships as evidence of a continuing commercial connection, although the precise nature of any beneficial ownership or operational control is plainly a matter in which careful distinctions must be maintained.


Evapify itself has disputed aspects of the alleged connections. In a statement reported by Business Insider Polska and reproduced in the Euromaidan Press investigation, the company said that Martins Baumanis, a former 4Finance executive who had created the Evapify brand, did not exercise a supervisory or operational role in the relevant businesses. A historical relationship between businessmen does not necessarily establish contemporary commercial control, just as evidence of a widespread illicit market does not establish that every person associated with its legitimate suppliers participates in smuggling. These are legitimate evidential questions that the journalists' investigation raises, and that deserve precise answers.


Yet the public importance of investigating these questions is undeniable. Smuggling, sanctions, international financial networks and the possible indirect enrichment of Russian business interests during the invasion of Ukraine are precisely the subjects upon which an independent press ought to concentrate its efforts. In a democratic society, powerful commercial figures cannot reasonably expect their international business connections to escape public scrutiny merely because the resulting questions are uncomfortable.


The response to the articles was rapid. According to information provided by Euromaidan Press editor-in-chief Alya Shandra to Ukraine's Institute of Mass Information, the publication received three legal demands in the days immediately following publication. Two came from Polish lawyers acting for parties associated with the Evapify businesses. They sought the removal of material and the publication of apologies, with deadlines reportedly measured in hours rather than weeks.


On 8 June 2026, the publication received a further demand from the Ukrainian law firm Burchills Ukraine, representing Boyko's interests. According to the Institute of Mass Information, the lawyers demanded that both articles be removed, that a prescribed retraction be published and that the planned third instalment of the investigation should not appear. Euromaidan Press also reported warnings concerning possible complaints to hosting providers and internet platforms. The publication refused the demands and offered the individuals concerned an opportunity to respond.


It is this last aspect of the dispute that raises particularly troubling questions.

A request to correct inaccurate reporting is a perfectly legitimate exercise of legal rights. A demand that journalists publish a retraction of statements shown to be false may likewise be entirely reasonable. Indeed, the existence of effective legal remedies against false allegations is one of the characteristics that distinguishes a mature democratic society from an environment in which reputations can be destroyed without accountability.


But a demand that journalists abandon an investigation before its next instalment has even been published is a substantially different matter. It raises the possibility of prior restraint upon expression, an interference that democratic legal systems traditionally approach with particular caution. The public interest in investigative journalism would be gravely diminished if wealthy individuals could suppress future reporting simply by expressing displeasure at what had already been published.


The distinction between correcting a false statement and preventing the publication of further information lies close to the heart of press freedom. The former protects the integrity of public debate. The latter risks extinguishing that debate altogether.


There is a recognised international expression for litigation brought principally to intimidate or silence those participating in public discussion: a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, commonly abbreviated to SLAPP. Such proceedings may exploit the disparity in resources between a wealthy claimant and a comparatively modest newspaper, civil society organisation or individual journalist. Even where the claimant ultimately fails, the financial costs, diversion of editorial resources and psychological burden of litigation may themselves achieve much of the intended effect.


It would be premature to characterise the present proceedings conclusively as a SLAPP. The claimant's full pleadings, the evidence relied upon and the defendant's response would need to be examined before such a judgment could responsibly be made. The broader history of legal demands nevertheless raises legitimate questions about whether the objective is confined to correcting particular alleged inaccuracies or extends to discouraging further investigation.


The European Union has recognised this problem in Directive 2024/1069, adopted in April 2024, which provides safeguards against manifestly unfounded or abusive civil proceedings brought in response to public participation. The Directive addresses cross-border litigation and establishes mechanisms including the early dismissal of certain claims. Its provisions do not automatically govern proceedings in a Ukrainian court, since Ukraine is not an EU member state, but they illustrate the growing European recognition that access to legal process can itself be misused to suppress public discussion.


Ukraine's own legal system has developed principles that are equally important. Her Supreme Court has repeatedly distinguished between allegations of fact, which are susceptible to proof or disproof, and expressions of opinion, which cannot generally be subjected to the same test of factual truth. In a judgment of 1 June 2026, the Supreme Court reiterated that the protection of honour and business reputation must be reconciled with the constitutional protection of freedom of expression and the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights.


This is no mere technicality of defamation law. When journalists describe an international commercial network as suspicious, politically compromised or morally objectionable, they may be expressing assessments based upon facts that have already entered the public domain. The underlying facts must be reported accurately, but the evaluative conclusions drawn from them are not necessarily susceptible to the same process of verification.

The European Court of Human Rights has long accepted that the limits of permissible criticism are wider where public figures and questions of public interest are concerned. In Lingens v Austria, decided in 1986, the Court emphasised the distinction between factual allegations and value judgments and the essential contribution of robust criticism to democratic debate. Powerful business figures cannot be equated in every respect with elected politicians, but those whose commercial activities intersect with public policy, sanctions and national security must expect searching examination of their conduct.


There is an additional difficulty when the subject is the commercial architecture of contemporary Russian wealth. International corporate structures frequently involve several jurisdictions, layers of holding companies, nominee arrangements, professional intermediaries and networks of former executives. These arrangements may be perfectly lawful, but they can also make it difficult to identify who ultimately exercises influence over a commercial enterprise.


Journalists examining these structures must therefore be especially careful about the difference between ownership, influence, association and control. The fact that a businessman once owned shares in a company does not necessarily mean that he continues to control businesses established by its former executives. Equally, the absence of formal share ownership does not conclusively establish the absence of influence.


Such questions cannot be resolved merely by applying labels. They require examination of corporate records, financial transactions, beneficial ownership declarations and the practical exercise of decision-making authority. The appropriate response to an investigation that raises these questions should ordinarily be the production of contrary evidence and an explanation of the relevant corporate relationships, rather than an attempt to prevent further questions being asked.


There is also an important distinction between the illicit electronic cigarette market as a whole and any particular commercial network operating within it. Even if the estimated 7.6 billion hryvnias in lost tax revenues is accurate, that figure cannot simply be attributed to Boyko or Evapify. To establish such an attribution would require evidence tracing particular products, transactions, profits or control relationships. Journalists have an obligation to respect these evidential boundaries, particularly where their reporting may cause serious reputational harm.


But the existence of such boundaries should not be confused with an obligation to remain silent. Investigative journalism often begins with incomplete information. Its function is to identify matters requiring explanation, assemble available evidence and invite further examination by the public and the competent authorities. If journalists were forbidden to report until every potential legal question had been resolved beyond dispute, much investigative journalism would never appear.


This is particularly important in Ukraine during wartime. The war has placed extraordinary pressure upon the country's institutions, from its police and prosecutors to its courts, customs authorities and financial regulators. Public scrutiny is not an inconvenience to these institutions but an indispensable supplement to their work. Journalists often identify suspicious activity, corruption or administrative failure long before formal investigations have reached any conclusion.


Nor should the importance of this principle be diminished merely because the journalist works for an English-language publication. Euromaidan Press performs a significant role in communicating Ukrainian affairs to an international audience, including readers whose governments provide military, financial and diplomatic assistance to Ukraine. Investigations into sanctions inconsistencies and the movement of capital through European commercial networks are therefore matters of concern not merely to Ukrainian readers but to the international community that supports the country's survival.


The wider question is whether the financial resources available to an individual should determine the intensity of scrutiny to which that individual can be subjected. Wealthy litigants can ordinarily afford specialist lawyers, proceedings in multiple jurisdictions and prolonged legal correspondence. Independent journalists frequently operate with considerably narrower financial margins. Even the prospect of paying lawyers to defend a thoroughly researched article can discourage publication, especially where a small editorial organisation cannot readily absorb unexpected expenses.


This imbalance does not mean that wealthy people should be deprived of their legal rights. It means that courts must remain alert to the possibility that the legal process is being employed for objectives beyond the vindication of legitimate grievances. The administration of justice must protect reputation without allowing the expense of protecting that reputation to become an instrument for silencing criticism.


There is a particular irony in the fact that these questions are now being examined in Ukraine. Russia has systematically suppressed independent journalism, placed journalists under criminal investigation for reporting accurately upon the invasion and constructed an increasingly elaborate legal apparatus designed to eliminate unwelcome public discussion. Ukraine, by contrast, has fought to preserve a political order in which the press may criticise public officials, scrutinise private wealth and investigate uncomfortable connections without fear of arbitrary punishment.


It would be a serious mistake to imagine that defending press freedom requires Ukrainian judges to favour journalists automatically. Courts must decide disputes according to law and evidence, not by reference to the nationality or political reputation of a claimant. A Russian citizen should enjoy the same procedural protections as anyone else bringing a properly founded civil claim. That is precisely what distinguishes the rule of law from political retaliation.


But the converse proposition is equally important. The courts must not become instruments through which wealth and legal sophistication can obtain restrictions upon legitimate reporting that could not otherwise be justified. The public interest in understanding the international finances of sanctioned Russian businessmen is exceptionally strong, particularly during a war in which financial resources, sanctions enforcement and the integrity of cross-border trade have become matters of national survival.


The forthcoming hearing in Kyiv therefore represents more than an ordinary dispute about the reputation of a businessman. It concerns the practical boundaries of investigative journalism, the ability of independent publications to withstand legal pressure and the willingness of the Ukrainian judicial system to reconcile private legal rights with the public's need for information.


We should not prejudge the outcome. Boyko is entitled to contest allegations he considers false, just as Euromaidan Press is entitled to defend the accuracy, public interest and legitimacy of its reporting. The court must examine the precise statements complained of, the evidence supporting them and the remedies properly available under Ukrainian law. Its task is not to decide whether it approves of either party, but whether the legal claims have been established.


Yet there is one broader conclusion that can already be drawn. A democratic society is not strengthened when powerful people are immune from criticism, nor when journalists are immune from responsibility. It is strengthened when inconvenient allegations can be published, tested, answered and, where necessary, corrected without the machinery of justice becoming an instrument of intimidation.


Ukraine's struggle against Russian aggression is not confined to the trenches, the drone factories or the diplomatic conference rooms of Western capitals. It is also a struggle over the character of the society that will emerge from the war. The preservation of independent institutions, including a judiciary capable of protecting both lawful reputation and freedom of expression, is among the things for which Ukrainians are fighting.


When the parties assemble in the Shevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv on 17 November, the immediate legal questions may appear narrow. They will concern the wording of particular articles, the character of corporate relationships and the legal consequences of allegedly inaccurate reporting. But beyond these questions lies a matter of enduring significance: whether a country resisting authoritarian aggression can preserve the intellectual and institutional freedom necessary to ensure that its victory is worth having.


The measure of a free society is not that its journalists are always correct, nor that its wealthy citizens are always wrong. It is that nobody, however influential, can purchase exemption from legitimate public scrutiny, and nobody, however unpopular, is denied justice merely because the exercise of their rights is inconvenient.


That is the standard to which Ukraine's courts should aspire. And it is a standard that the country's independent journalists must be free to defend.


---


Editorial note: Written on 16 November 2026, ahead of the scheduled hearing. The court's opening order and the two published investigations have been examined, together with the Institute of Mass Information's account of the pre-litigation correspondence. The full statement of claim and defence submissions were not available for examination. No determination of the merits of the lawsuit is implied.

 
 

Note from Matthew Parish, Editor-in-Chief. The Lviv Herald is a unique and independent source of analytical journalism about the war in Ukraine and its aftermath, and all the geopolitical and diplomatic consequences of the war as well as the tremendous advances in military technology the war has yielded. To achieve this independence, we rely exclusively on donations. Please donate if you can, with the buttons at the top of this page.

Copyright (c) Lviv Herald 2024-26. All rights reserved.  Accredited by the Armed Forces of Ukraine after approval by the State Security Service of Ukraine. To view our policy on the anonymity of authors, please click the "About" page.

bottom of page